Thriving Areas in Shelby County, KY

Shelby County, Kentucky, has been buzzing with real estate activity over the past year, and homebuyers and sellers alike have had their eyes fixed on several standout subdivisions and popular neighborhoods. Today, we’re diving deep into the recent trends and highlights from some of the most sought-after areas in Shelby County, helping you understand what’s been selling and at what price points. Whether you’re thinking about buying, selling, or simply keeping an eye on local market trends, here’s everything you need to know.

Bagdad

Bagdad remains a hotspot for buyers seeking peaceful properties with plenty of acreage. Notable sales include a sprawling 102-acre estate on Benson Pike that fetched $925,000. Other highlights include properties on Miles Lane, Elmburg Road, and Vigo Road, all attracting attention for their expansive lots ranging from 5 to over 15 acres. Prices here ranged broadly, from $149,900 for older properties to upwards of $521,500 for newer or renovated homes.

Finchville

In Finchville, Clark Station Road made a statement with impressive sales, including a premium property that sold for $900,000 at a price per square foot of $274.14. Finchville also continues to draw buyers looking for a combination of rural charm and convenient accessibility, with homes on Taylorsville Road quickly selling at attractive price points between $293,000 and $355,000.

Ardmore Crossing

These two neighborhoods in Shelbyville saw significant activity over the past year, making them popular choices for growing families and those seeking newer construction. Ardmore Crossing featured several transactions, such as a home at 254 Ardmore Crossing Dr, fetching around $401,000. Dry Run Ct in particular had multiple sales, demonstrating strong demand with homes consistently selling between $345,000 and $415,000.

Fairway Crossing

Fairway Crossing and Clubhouse Drive stood out for their appeal to buyers who appreciate suburban amenities and a community-oriented atmosphere. Properties like 37 Fairway Crossing and 147 Clubhouse Dr sold in the mid to upper $300s, reflecting stable values in a desirable neighborhood with mature landscaping and convenient access.

Bridlewood Estates

Bridlewood Ave saw a wave of activity with homes rapidly moving off the market, often selling above the listing price—a clear indicator of its desirability. Prices here typically ranged between $279,000 and $305,000, with most properties spending less than 10 days on the market.

Discovery Pointe

Exploration Path and Knowledge Point Path are newer developments attracting buyers interested in contemporary layouts and fresh builds. Homes in these neighborhoods showed a broad range, with price points mostly falling between $299,000 and $399,000, indicating robust interest in modern living spaces and turnkey homes.

Magnolia Avenue & Historic Shelbyville

Magnolia Avenue and surrounding historic areas remained charming choices for buyers looking for character and convenience. Homes on Magnolia Ave fetched between $225,000 and $469,000, highlighting the varied inventory from cozy starters to spacious family homes with historical significance.

Rural Estates and Acreage

Properties with acreage in Shelbyville continued to attract premium buyers, reflecting the ongoing appeal of countryside living. Notably, large-acreage properties on Cropper Road, Dover Rd, and Locust Grove Rd had significant transactions, with prices ranging up to $3.58 million, demonstrating that the luxury and equestrian market remains highly active.

Final Thoughts

Shelby County’s real estate market remains vibrant, diverse, and highly competitive. As you explore your next move, understanding these trends can position you perfectly for success. From sprawling estates to charming city neighborhoods, there’s a unique opportunity here for every lifestyle.

Ready to dive deeper? Contact our team today—we’d love to guide you to your perfect Shelby County home!

Podcast Suggestion: Check out the episode “Real Estate Market Trends 2025: What Buyers & Sellers Need to Know” from “The BiggerPockets Real Estate Podcast.”

Healthy Meal Tip: Try grilling lemon garlic chicken thighs with fresh rosemary and veggies—a delicious gluten-free and dairy-free meal perfect for the grill!